Best Almond Butter Substitute

Don’t have that nut butter or are you working around an allergy? Here is the best almond butter substitute for toast or in recipes.

Are you making a recipe that calls for almond butter and you don’t have any? Or deal with a nut allergy? Almond butter is of course one of the most popular nut butters and still plays second fiddle to its popular peanut butter cousin. It has a neutral flavor and is great to drizzle over almost anything. It’s perfect on almond butter toast, but is also used in pastries. Need a replacement? Here is the best almond butter substitute.

Best Almond Butter Substitute

1. Sunflower Butter

The Best Almond Butter Substitute When Bypassing a Nut Allergy? sunflower butter! This sunflower seed butter is a widely accepted substitute for any type of nut butter. It’s creamy and has a neutral flavor, similar to almond butter. You can find it at your local grocery store or you can make it at home.

Remember: when you add sunflower butter to a baked good, it can turn a green color due to a chemical reaction with the baking powder or baking soda! It’s safe to eat, according to the Sunbutter website. They suggest reducing baking powder or baking soda in pastries by ⅓.

2. Pumpkin Seed Butter

Another good almond butter substitute for a nut allergy? Pumpkin Seed Butter! This creamy green butter is made from pumpkin seeds, also known as pepitas. You can find it at grocery stores or online, and it’s delicious! Whether you’re making toast or using it in pastries, it’s a great alternative to almond butter.

3. Peanut Butter

The most popular nut-based almond butter substitute? Peanut butter! Peanut butter is a natural substitute for almond butter in all nut butter applications. It has a milder flavor than almond butter, which is more neutral. It’s obviously very easy to find, or you can make homemade peanut butter.

4. Cashew Butter

Another great nut-based almond butter substitute? cashew butter! The creamy texture and slightly sweet taste of cashew butter makes a good substitute. You can use it anywhere you would use almond butter: toast or baking. Buy it or make our homemade cashew butter.

5. Pecan Butter

Another almond butter substitute? pecan butter! It’s even creamier and has a nuttier flavor than almond butter. It’s harder to find in grocery stores, but very easy to make at home! Try this Homemade Pecan Butter.

6. Pistachio Butter

Pistachio butter is another nut butter that substitutes for almond butter. It’s creamy and green: and it’s one of the best nut butters around! You can find it in the nut butter section of some grocery stores, online, or it’s easy to make at home.

7. Hazelnut Butter

Hazelnut butter is another nut butter that substitutes for almond butter. It’s creamy and has a nice nutty flavor (combine it with chocolate and it’s Nutella!). It’s more of a niche product, but you can find it in the nut butter section of some grocery stores or online.

8. Nut butter

One Last Substitute for Almond Butter? nut butter! The nut butter is creamy and has an ultra nutty taste. It can have a bitter aftertaste, so you can pair it with honey on toast. Find it in grocery stores, online, or make your own.

Here are some almond butter recipes where you could use this substitute: